Ustavni sud Bosne i Hercegovine
Odluka o meritumu u predmetu U-21/00 (A. H.)
Odluka donesena 22. 06. 2001.
- Obustava postupka - prestale pretpostavke za vođenje postupka
Predmeti (1)
U-21/00
Ocjena ustavnosti
Odluka o meritumu
22. 06. 2001.
Tekst odluke
CONSTITUTIONAL COURT OF BOSNIA
AND HERZEGOVINA
RULING
Having regard to Article VI.3 (b) of the Constitution of Bosnia and Herzegovina and Article 56 of the Court’s Rules of Procedure, at its session held on 2 and 3 February 2001, the Constitutional Court adopted the following
RULING
The proceedings upon the appeal submitted by A.H. from Jajce, requesting repossession of the real property situated in Jajce, Baščeluci Street, and the house built on Cadastre Unit 268/2 with an area of 964 maccording to the ruling of the Municipal Administration of Jajce
– Service for Civil Engineering, Urbanism, Geodesy, Cadastre and Property and Legal Issues No. 05-372-461/98 of 19 June 1998 and the Conclusion on the permission of execution of the aforesaid ruling, adopted by the Mayor of Municipality of Jajce, No. 05-372-461/00 of 25 April 2000, is terminated.
This ruling shall be submitted to the appellant and to the Municipal Administration of Jajce.
REASONS
1. The Appeal
In her appeal, which was received by the Constitutional Court on 10 July 2000, the appellant, A. H. from Jajce, requested the protection of her rights to peaceful enjoyment of her property and respect for her home, as guaranteed by Article 1 of Protocol No.1 to the European Convention on Human Rights and Article 8 of the Convention, respectively, as well as by Article II.3 (k) and (f) of the Constitution of Bosnia and Herzegovina.
The appellant stated that she had had to leave her home and her property on 29 October 1992, due to war conditions, and that she had then lived as a refugee in Bjelovar in the Republic of Croatia. She had lost her status of a refugee on 13 September 1995 and was forced to pay the rent. She believes that the temporary user of her property, P.L. from Dobretić no longer has any legal basis for use of her property in Jajce since the ruling of the competent body of the Municipality of Jajce, No. 05-372-461/98 of 19 June 1998, terminated the administering of her property by the authorities.
It was also decided that the property shall be returned to her possession. Consequently, the temporary user of the property, P. L., would no longer be entitled to use the property. Ruling No. 05-372/97 of 1 December 1997 on the temporary use of the property in question is now without legal force. The temporary user P. L. was given a time-limit of 90 days from the above ruling to leave the property and was advised he was entitled to an emergency accommodation. Case No. U 21/00 Ruling
In accordance with Article 275 of Law on Administrative Proceedings ("Official Gazette of Federation of BiH", No. 2/87) and upon the appellant's request, the Mayor of the Municipality adopted the conclusion No. 05.372-461/98 of 19 June 1998 on the permission of the execution of that ruling, which established that the abovementioned administrative ruling became executive thus permitting its execution within 5 days from the receipt of this conclusion since the temporary user of the property did not act in accordance with the ruling of the competent body of the Municipality of Jajce.
2. The Facts of the Case and the Legal Situation
Having been given the opportunity to comment on the appeal, the Service for Civil Engineering, Urbanism, Geodesy, Cadastre and Administrative and Legal Issues of the Municipality of Jajce informed the Constitutional Court in its answer No. 05-372-461/98 of 26 October 2000, that the appellant’s property in Jajce, situated at 7 Baščeluci Street had been returned to her on 30 August 2000. They also submitted the minutes of on-site inspection of the object as well as the minutes on the owner's repossession of the property.
3. The Conclusion
It follows that the violation of the right the appellant complained of to the Constitutional Court, has been resolved and therefore it was ruled as in the operative clause.
According to Article VI.4 of the Constitution of Bosnia and Herzegovina, the decisions of the Constitutional Court are final and binding.
The Court ruled in the following composition: President of the Court Prof. Dr. Kasim Begić and Judges Hans Danelius, Prof. Dr. Louis Favoreu, Prof. Dr. Joseph Marko, Dr. Zvonko Miljko, Azra Omeragić, Prof. Dr. Vitomir Popović, Prof. Dr. Snežana Savić and Mirko Zovko.
U 21/00
2 February 2001
Sarajevo
Presidentof the Constitutional Court of Bosnia and Herzegovina
Prof. Dr. Kasim Begić
Proceedings before the Constitutional Court may be terminated if the reasons for the appeal cease to exist.